This is the second autobiography that I've read in a row and this one was completely different in some ways - here terminal illness was the enemy rather than an autocratic state. Yet, it was similar in that it showed the absolute strength of the human spirit when it is most severely challenged.
Paul Kalanithi, who succumbed to lung cancer in 2015, was a brilliant neurosurgeon/neuroscientist who was just about to complete his specialty when he was struck by the cancer. Prior to medical school he had studied English literature and the history and philosophy of science and medicine so had also dreamed of eventually writing a book. He was originally moved to study the brain in order to understand how something as complex and language and communication could be physically explained. With his patients he was always fascinated by the process of dying and how the patient and the families came to terms with it.
So, when faced with his own mortality he set out to write a book that would document his dying process and serve as a guide for others facing the same circumstances (which he recognized is everyone at some point - they just don't always know when). Personally, not being that philosophical, I found myself skimming some of the more esoteric sections, but I was fascinated by Kalanithi's personal story. I also enjoyed how he wove in applicable passages from literature. The epilogue by Kalanithi's wife, which outlines his last few days and his literal deathbed request that his family see his book through to publication, was also extremely moving.
At times depressing, at other times hopeful, this was a very interesting read by someone with a perspective that we don't often get to share. This is not an easy read and I don't recommend it for mere entertainment, but it does contain some insights that are helpful, if not pleasant, to share.
The answer to the question I'm always asked about what I'm reading and whether I recommend it.
Monday, May 2, 2016
Tuesday, April 5, 2016
Until We are Free - My Fight for Human Rights in Iran by Shirin Ebadi
Shirin Ebadi is a human rights activist from Iran - and the first Muslim female to win the Nobel Peace Prize. This book is the story of her life of fighting for the rights of women, political activists, Bahai and other oppressed minorities in Iran.
Prior to the Iranian revolution, Ebadi was a judge. When the Shah was overthrown the new Islamic regime stripped all women of their judgeships, feeling women were too emotional to make legal decisions. Ebadi didn't let this deter her - she took up the cause of human rights law, working through the courts and political channels to try to uphold the rights of the oppressed. She went about it in a very intelligent and systematic way, even using Islam to her advantage in arguing her cases. Because she would never back down, she became a regular target of the Islamic regime - they tried everything to intimidate her. Her situation worsened with the "election" of Ahmadinejad - she was stopped from appearing in court, holding events, speaking her mind and even spent some time in Evin prison. However, the government stopped short of killing her or permanently imprisoning her - likely because it feared the international backlash of treating a Nobel prize winner in this way.
On the eve of Ahmadinejad's second term, Ebadi was traveling outside the country (she would not be intimidated into abandoning speaking on the world stage - even when her daughter was used as a pawn). She has not been able to return to Iran due to threats against her and she continues her work from the UK and the US (she has one daughter living in each country). After she left the country and continued to speak out against the regime, the government used her husband to try to silence her, eventually wearing him down and breaking up what was a very solid marriage. She does hold out some hope of improvement under Rouhani, but it sounds like there is still a long way to go.
The book is well written, easy to read and highly educational. While I was aware of the oppressive regime in Iran, it was still eye opening to hear it from the perspective of someone who has lived through it. Some of the stories she tells are unimaginable. I recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in international human rights.
Prior to the Iranian revolution, Ebadi was a judge. When the Shah was overthrown the new Islamic regime stripped all women of their judgeships, feeling women were too emotional to make legal decisions. Ebadi didn't let this deter her - she took up the cause of human rights law, working through the courts and political channels to try to uphold the rights of the oppressed. She went about it in a very intelligent and systematic way, even using Islam to her advantage in arguing her cases. Because she would never back down, she became a regular target of the Islamic regime - they tried everything to intimidate her. Her situation worsened with the "election" of Ahmadinejad - she was stopped from appearing in court, holding events, speaking her mind and even spent some time in Evin prison. However, the government stopped short of killing her or permanently imprisoning her - likely because it feared the international backlash of treating a Nobel prize winner in this way.
On the eve of Ahmadinejad's second term, Ebadi was traveling outside the country (she would not be intimidated into abandoning speaking on the world stage - even when her daughter was used as a pawn). She has not been able to return to Iran due to threats against her and she continues her work from the UK and the US (she has one daughter living in each country). After she left the country and continued to speak out against the regime, the government used her husband to try to silence her, eventually wearing him down and breaking up what was a very solid marriage. She does hold out some hope of improvement under Rouhani, but it sounds like there is still a long way to go.
The book is well written, easy to read and highly educational. While I was aware of the oppressive regime in Iran, it was still eye opening to hear it from the perspective of someone who has lived through it. Some of the stories she tells are unimaginable. I recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in international human rights.
Friday, April 1, 2016
The Age of Reinvention by Karine Tuil
I have very mixed feelings about this book. I found the story itself really interesting. Sam Tahar is a very successful New York litigator who seems to have it all - great job, rich wife with connections into all aspects of society, plenty of affairs... The only problem is it is all based on a lie. Sam is really Samir Tahar - raised a poor Muslim in a Paris slum. He works hard and does well in law school but when he is unable to get a job, he changes the name on his resume to Sam and is immediately hired by a Jewish lawyer in Paris who assumes he is also Jewish.
Sam lets the assumption continue and, when he is asked to move to New York and open an office there, he carries it further. He adopts the past of a law school friend, Samuel Baron, who really is Jewish and manages to marry into one of New York's elite Jewish families.
The only thing Samir was unable to take from Samuel was the woman he most wanted, Nina. Samir and Nina have a brief affair during law school (while Samuel is off burying his parents which tells you a lot about Samir's empathy). When Samuel returns he is devastated and attempts suicide so Nina chooses him over Samir. At the start of the book they are barely getting by. Everything changes when they read about Samir and realize what he has done. They decide to contact him - Samuel wants to test Nina's resolve. This ends up having disastrous consequences for all three. But, surprisingly, though Samir lets his guard down in order to be with Nina, she is not the ultimate cause of his downfall - but I don't want to give the book away so I will not describe the events that lead to his life unravelling (and Samuel's simultaneous rise in fortunes).
What I didn't like about the book was the writing style. I found it very pompous - one of my pet peeves is footnotes in fiction and these were used liberally. There were also many passages where alternate thoughts were expressed with back slashes. I just found it annoying - like the author was attempting to show off her wide vocabulary. I will give credit to the translator - if the author's annoying pomposity could come through in translation, I think the translator must be top notch. I don't remember, but I must have heard about this book in the New York Times as it is exactly the kind of writing style the Times always praises; like the book editors must show how smart they are by relating to this "high brow" writing.
In the end I don't strongly recommend this book. I made it through because I wanted to see how Tahar's life unravelled but I wouldn't say I truly enjoyed the read.
Sam lets the assumption continue and, when he is asked to move to New York and open an office there, he carries it further. He adopts the past of a law school friend, Samuel Baron, who really is Jewish and manages to marry into one of New York's elite Jewish families.
The only thing Samir was unable to take from Samuel was the woman he most wanted, Nina. Samir and Nina have a brief affair during law school (while Samuel is off burying his parents which tells you a lot about Samir's empathy). When Samuel returns he is devastated and attempts suicide so Nina chooses him over Samir. At the start of the book they are barely getting by. Everything changes when they read about Samir and realize what he has done. They decide to contact him - Samuel wants to test Nina's resolve. This ends up having disastrous consequences for all three. But, surprisingly, though Samir lets his guard down in order to be with Nina, she is not the ultimate cause of his downfall - but I don't want to give the book away so I will not describe the events that lead to his life unravelling (and Samuel's simultaneous rise in fortunes).
What I didn't like about the book was the writing style. I found it very pompous - one of my pet peeves is footnotes in fiction and these were used liberally. There were also many passages where alternate thoughts were expressed with back slashes. I just found it annoying - like the author was attempting to show off her wide vocabulary. I will give credit to the translator - if the author's annoying pomposity could come through in translation, I think the translator must be top notch. I don't remember, but I must have heard about this book in the New York Times as it is exactly the kind of writing style the Times always praises; like the book editors must show how smart they are by relating to this "high brow" writing.
In the end I don't strongly recommend this book. I made it through because I wanted to see how Tahar's life unravelled but I wouldn't say I truly enjoyed the read.
Sunday, March 20, 2016
The Reason You Walk by Wab Kinew
This was a difficult but important book to read - I think every Canadian should read it to gain greater understanding of our Aboriginal population. Kinew is the son of a residential school survivor. His book is really the story of his father, the survivor. While it covers the period of his father's childhood, adulthood and beyond, the focus is on the relationship the men develop in the year leading up to his father's death from cancer.
Kinew's father, Tobasonakwut or Ndede (Ojibwe for my father), was plucked from his parent's home at the age of five. He was forced into a residential school where he was emotionally, physically and sexually abused by both nuns and priests. The leaders of the school took seriously their goal of beating the Indian out of these children. Ndede told horrific stories of a friend who was beaten to death while the priests looked on, or being beaten for not kneeling at his father's grave (the Ojibwe tradition is to stand rather than kneel). Miraculously, after a bout with drinking and fighting, Ndede stayed away from alcohol and focused on his education. He also had three children from a first failed relationship. Unfortunately his anger and inability to show love continued - and one of these children committed suicide. A second was killed young in a car accident.
While in Toronto, Ndede met the woman who would become Kinew's mother, an upper middle class white woman whose open minded family accepted him better than most might have. She moved to a reserve and then Winnipeg with him and together they had two children, Kinew and his sister, Shawon. He did stray one more time and had another daughter, but remained married to Kinew's mother until his death.
Kinew himself struggled with alcoholism and fighting in his twenties but pulled himself together for his sons - and became a very successful journalist. But his honest account of his family life showed how the residential schools have a lasting effect on generations of families. Children taken from their homes do not have role models for parenting, and are angry and have been abused. They thus have difficulties showing love and raising their own children - who then, sadly, can carry that experience to the next generation.
Kinew describes incredible native traditions (especially the sundance) which he shares in with his father and other family members. He also captures the paradox of his father's continuing interest in the Catholic traditions - there are amazing scenes of his father giving the Pope two Eagle feathers - which the Pope accepted and Ndede took as a sign of reconciliation; and a ceremony where he adopts the Archbishop of Winnipeg as his brother. Though the most poignant scene was his forgiveness of the Archbishop on his death bed.
One of my favourite stories was a legacy Kinew has left for all Canadians - when he was a young journalist at CBC Winnipeg, the ethics committee sent a memo saying residential school survivors should not be called survivors as they did not fit the definition. Instead they should be called "former students". Kinew sent a memo reasoning with the ethics committee - saying in fact they did fit the definition and, moreover, it would do a disservice to merely call them students which in future generations would convey the wrong message. He was initially rejected and threatened to quit his position over it, but ultimately with the support of more senior reporters successfully changed the CBC's official position on the use of the word survivor.
While occasionally the writing style was hard to follow - I sometimes forgot who various players were and there were a lot of Ojibwe expressions which are explained but are difficult words to parse for non-Ojibwe speakers - this did not detract from the readability of the book and, as I said above, I think this is a really important book to read too.
Kinew's father, Tobasonakwut or Ndede (Ojibwe for my father), was plucked from his parent's home at the age of five. He was forced into a residential school where he was emotionally, physically and sexually abused by both nuns and priests. The leaders of the school took seriously their goal of beating the Indian out of these children. Ndede told horrific stories of a friend who was beaten to death while the priests looked on, or being beaten for not kneeling at his father's grave (the Ojibwe tradition is to stand rather than kneel). Miraculously, after a bout with drinking and fighting, Ndede stayed away from alcohol and focused on his education. He also had three children from a first failed relationship. Unfortunately his anger and inability to show love continued - and one of these children committed suicide. A second was killed young in a car accident.
While in Toronto, Ndede met the woman who would become Kinew's mother, an upper middle class white woman whose open minded family accepted him better than most might have. She moved to a reserve and then Winnipeg with him and together they had two children, Kinew and his sister, Shawon. He did stray one more time and had another daughter, but remained married to Kinew's mother until his death.
Kinew himself struggled with alcoholism and fighting in his twenties but pulled himself together for his sons - and became a very successful journalist. But his honest account of his family life showed how the residential schools have a lasting effect on generations of families. Children taken from their homes do not have role models for parenting, and are angry and have been abused. They thus have difficulties showing love and raising their own children - who then, sadly, can carry that experience to the next generation.
Kinew describes incredible native traditions (especially the sundance) which he shares in with his father and other family members. He also captures the paradox of his father's continuing interest in the Catholic traditions - there are amazing scenes of his father giving the Pope two Eagle feathers - which the Pope accepted and Ndede took as a sign of reconciliation; and a ceremony where he adopts the Archbishop of Winnipeg as his brother. Though the most poignant scene was his forgiveness of the Archbishop on his death bed.
One of my favourite stories was a legacy Kinew has left for all Canadians - when he was a young journalist at CBC Winnipeg, the ethics committee sent a memo saying residential school survivors should not be called survivors as they did not fit the definition. Instead they should be called "former students". Kinew sent a memo reasoning with the ethics committee - saying in fact they did fit the definition and, moreover, it would do a disservice to merely call them students which in future generations would convey the wrong message. He was initially rejected and threatened to quit his position over it, but ultimately with the support of more senior reporters successfully changed the CBC's official position on the use of the word survivor.
While occasionally the writing style was hard to follow - I sometimes forgot who various players were and there were a lot of Ojibwe expressions which are explained but are difficult words to parse for non-Ojibwe speakers - this did not detract from the readability of the book and, as I said above, I think this is a really important book to read too.
Saturday, March 12, 2016
Niko by Dimitri Nasrallah
Though I had ordered this book from the library some time ago, I almost didn't read it since I have read so many refugee stories lately and I wasn't sure I felt like another one. But I'm glad I decided to go through with it. The story was written in a very different style than the others. Firstly, it was written from several points of view - Niko, his father, his aunt and uncle... Moreover, when the book begins Niko is only about 6 years old so we see the action (particularly the Lebanese civil war and the death of his mother) from the perspective of a child.
After Niko's mother is killed by a car bomb and his father's store is also destroyed, Niko and his father flee Lebanon. Unfortunately they don't have a very well developed plan and literally drift from Cyprus, to a Greek island to Athens. When his money begins to run out and the father is unable to renew his passport (it is never totally clear whether this is because of the turmoil in Lebanon or because he is a Palestinian refugee rather than a Lebanese citizen), he sends Niko to Montreal to live with an aunt and uncle who he has never met. The aunt is his mother's estranged sister, married to a much older man who was her father's employer.
The narrative continues for the next decade or so as Niko is unable to fit in with his new family and peers in Canada as he holds back a bit in the hopes this is temporary and he will be reunited with his family. We also see his father struggle to make something of himself before he can get to Niko - he works odd jobs on ships from Marseilles and Libya and eventually ends up in Chile. But fate intervenes and he is unable to connect with his son for years.
I think this was so interesting as it shows the lengths a father will go to in order to improve his son's life, but how his efforts are at least part in vain because his son feels abandoned by the one person he has come to count on. It also shows yet again how hard it is to establish oneself in a new country when the comfortable life you used to know is shattered by war.
After Niko's mother is killed by a car bomb and his father's store is also destroyed, Niko and his father flee Lebanon. Unfortunately they don't have a very well developed plan and literally drift from Cyprus, to a Greek island to Athens. When his money begins to run out and the father is unable to renew his passport (it is never totally clear whether this is because of the turmoil in Lebanon or because he is a Palestinian refugee rather than a Lebanese citizen), he sends Niko to Montreal to live with an aunt and uncle who he has never met. The aunt is his mother's estranged sister, married to a much older man who was her father's employer.
The narrative continues for the next decade or so as Niko is unable to fit in with his new family and peers in Canada as he holds back a bit in the hopes this is temporary and he will be reunited with his family. We also see his father struggle to make something of himself before he can get to Niko - he works odd jobs on ships from Marseilles and Libya and eventually ends up in Chile. But fate intervenes and he is unable to connect with his son for years.
I think this was so interesting as it shows the lengths a father will go to in order to improve his son's life, but how his efforts are at least part in vain because his son feels abandoned by the one person he has come to count on. It also shows yet again how hard it is to establish oneself in a new country when the comfortable life you used to know is shattered by war.
Monday, March 7, 2016
The One Hundred Year Walk - An Armenian Odyssey by Dawn Anahid MacKeen
I loved this book - and it was so enlightening. I knew a little bit about the Armenian genocide, but this book really brought it to life - in all its horror.
First of all I can't say enough about how well the format of the book worked. The author, a journalist, is encouraged by her mother to tell her grandfather's story. While she vaguely remembers her grandfather, and grew up hearing her mother's stories about his survival of the genocide, she is not convinced to take on the project until she finds her grandfather's journals. At first she is missing the most crucial years of the genocide, but after much searching they are found in her uncle's garage. She then works with her mother and her mother's friends and relatives to translate them from Armenian to English. She also studies everything she can find about the genocide (which is less than she would have hoped). Armed with this historical information, she retraces the route her grandfather was forced to walk when the Turks led the Armenians on a death march during World War I. The chapters of the book alternate between Dawn's quest and that of her grandfather. And she had enough information to convincingly write her grandfather's chapters in the first person from his perspective.
Dawn's grandfather, Stepan, was a courier in Adabazar, a town in the Ottoman Empire not far from Constantinople. The town had a large, vibrant Armenian population prior to its being swept up in a mass government deportation. Stepan himself is drafted into an army work gang which is first overworked and underfed clearing roads and railway lines. Eventually they are just led on a long march through the desert - and Stepan gradually comes to the realization that they are being led to their deaths. At the same time his family is deported to a refugee camp in a place called Chai and are miraculously able to stick together and stay there until the end of the war.
Stepan survives through a combination of incredible will and ingenuity, bonds with fellow residents of Adabazar who he meets along the way and, at times, just plain luck. He escapes more than once, only to be returned to his doomed march though makes his final escape with the assistance of an Arab sheik in what is present-day Syria. He works as his assistant under the sheik's protection until it is relatively safe for him to return to Anatolia to reunite with his family.
Dawn realizes her grandfather's strength when she is unable to cope with the walks he used to take as a courier and has trouble crossing the desert in a car with provisions. She is able to locate the descendants of the sheik who saved her grandfather's life and is greeted by 300 of them - where she is able to convey her family's thanks.
The description of the tortuous conditions the Armenians suffered are powerful; made more so by the fact that the current Turkish government still does not acknowledge the "Armenian issue" as an act of genocide. In fact, Dawn felt compelled to hide the true purpose of her visit to Turkey for fear of agitating the authorities. To this day the US has also feared calling the event a genocide - even though Dawn quotes from communiques from the US Ambassador at the time pleading with his government to intervene (he eventually resigns from his post as he finds it too hard to deal with). There are also interesting reports from German soldiers which make their way to the rest of the world but result in limited action - interesting because Germany was an ally of Turkey at the time and because similar reports coming out of Germany would be similarly ignored only a few decades later.
I highly recommend this book for anyone who wants to gain insight into an ugly era in human history - but told from a very human perspective.
First of all I can't say enough about how well the format of the book worked. The author, a journalist, is encouraged by her mother to tell her grandfather's story. While she vaguely remembers her grandfather, and grew up hearing her mother's stories about his survival of the genocide, she is not convinced to take on the project until she finds her grandfather's journals. At first she is missing the most crucial years of the genocide, but after much searching they are found in her uncle's garage. She then works with her mother and her mother's friends and relatives to translate them from Armenian to English. She also studies everything she can find about the genocide (which is less than she would have hoped). Armed with this historical information, she retraces the route her grandfather was forced to walk when the Turks led the Armenians on a death march during World War I. The chapters of the book alternate between Dawn's quest and that of her grandfather. And she had enough information to convincingly write her grandfather's chapters in the first person from his perspective.
Dawn's grandfather, Stepan, was a courier in Adabazar, a town in the Ottoman Empire not far from Constantinople. The town had a large, vibrant Armenian population prior to its being swept up in a mass government deportation. Stepan himself is drafted into an army work gang which is first overworked and underfed clearing roads and railway lines. Eventually they are just led on a long march through the desert - and Stepan gradually comes to the realization that they are being led to their deaths. At the same time his family is deported to a refugee camp in a place called Chai and are miraculously able to stick together and stay there until the end of the war.
Stepan survives through a combination of incredible will and ingenuity, bonds with fellow residents of Adabazar who he meets along the way and, at times, just plain luck. He escapes more than once, only to be returned to his doomed march though makes his final escape with the assistance of an Arab sheik in what is present-day Syria. He works as his assistant under the sheik's protection until it is relatively safe for him to return to Anatolia to reunite with his family.
Dawn realizes her grandfather's strength when she is unable to cope with the walks he used to take as a courier and has trouble crossing the desert in a car with provisions. She is able to locate the descendants of the sheik who saved her grandfather's life and is greeted by 300 of them - where she is able to convey her family's thanks.
The description of the tortuous conditions the Armenians suffered are powerful; made more so by the fact that the current Turkish government still does not acknowledge the "Armenian issue" as an act of genocide. In fact, Dawn felt compelled to hide the true purpose of her visit to Turkey for fear of agitating the authorities. To this day the US has also feared calling the event a genocide - even though Dawn quotes from communiques from the US Ambassador at the time pleading with his government to intervene (he eventually resigns from his post as he finds it too hard to deal with). There are also interesting reports from German soldiers which make their way to the rest of the world but result in limited action - interesting because Germany was an ally of Turkey at the time and because similar reports coming out of Germany would be similarly ignored only a few decades later.
I highly recommend this book for anyone who wants to gain insight into an ugly era in human history - but told from a very human perspective.
Monday, February 29, 2016
The Lightless Sky by Gunwale Passarlay with Nadine Ghouri
Given today's refugee crisis, this is a very timely personal account of a young boy's escape from Afghanistan to the west.
Gulwali Passarlay was born in 1994 in a small Pashtu community in Afghanistan. As a very young boy he lived a shepherd's life in the mountains with his grandparents. Later he helped his uncle's in a market tailoring shop. Gulwali's father was a well-respected doctor; his uncle a Taliban officer and his mother and other female relatives traditional women who generally stayed at home, but wore the full body blue burqa when they did venture out. Gulwali himself was taught to be deeply religious and to fight for the honour of his family and the superiority of the men in the community. He did not support educating his younger sisters.
When Gulwali was 12, and the Taliban had been chased from power by coalition forces, both the Taliban resistance and the invading armies tried to recruit him and his older brother. Instead his parents sent him away to live with his maternal grandparents in another Afghan village. While he was there both his father and grandfather were executed for collaboration with the Taliban. Because this book is written from Gulwali's perspective, as a child, we never really know the extent of their involvement with the Taliban. My personal view is they were just poor, traditional tribal villagers who were trying to survive however they could.
Gulwali's mother decides it is no longer safe for her oldest sons so she pays human smugglers to take them to freedom in Europe (we later find out she has paid $8000 each to get them as far as Greece). She accompanies them as far as Peshawar, Pakistan then instructs them to hold each other's hands the whole way and "no matter how hard it gets, never come back". These words haunt Gulwali throughout his lengthy escape. First, because he is separated from his brother by the smugglers in the Peshawar airport and must make the escape entirely on his own. Second, it gets really hard and he desperately longs for the comfort of his mother and grandmother.
Most of the book gives us insight into just how difficult escape is, and how organized a machine human smuggling has become. Gulwali travels from Pakistan to Iran, through Iran, on foot to Turkey, by train to Bulgaria - where he is jailed and returned to Turkey, where he is jailed and returned to Iran. Then from Iran back to Turkey, by leaky boat to Greece, then to Italy, Calais, France and finally England. Along the way he meets the worst of the smugglers who prey upon people's desperation. But he does meet up with some kindness - in other, slightly older, refugees boys who take him under their wing, some of the lowly hosts of refugees who are doing this just to make a living and take pity on a small boy doing this on his own (he is particularly favoured by some of the wives and mothers who feel for him and do what they can, whether it is giving him a bit extra food or slightly better sleeping conditions).
Some of the most vivid descriptions are of makeshift refugee camps in Europe - particularly "the jungle" in Calais. It's eye opening to see what is happening in these supposedly developed countries. In the end Gulwali makes it to the UK alive - but he is permanently scarred both physically (from an aborted attempt to smuggle him across the channel in a truck filled with some sort of chemical powder) and emotionally (he suffers from severe depression, and even attempts suicide at least twice). But he is obviously extremely bright and makes the most of his educational opportunities in the UK. He says he dreams of returning the Afghanistan and one day perhaps becoming its president. Given his remarkable survival skills, I for one believe he probably could become president of Afghanistan one day.
Gulwali Passarlay was born in 1994 in a small Pashtu community in Afghanistan. As a very young boy he lived a shepherd's life in the mountains with his grandparents. Later he helped his uncle's in a market tailoring shop. Gulwali's father was a well-respected doctor; his uncle a Taliban officer and his mother and other female relatives traditional women who generally stayed at home, but wore the full body blue burqa when they did venture out. Gulwali himself was taught to be deeply religious and to fight for the honour of his family and the superiority of the men in the community. He did not support educating his younger sisters.
When Gulwali was 12, and the Taliban had been chased from power by coalition forces, both the Taliban resistance and the invading armies tried to recruit him and his older brother. Instead his parents sent him away to live with his maternal grandparents in another Afghan village. While he was there both his father and grandfather were executed for collaboration with the Taliban. Because this book is written from Gulwali's perspective, as a child, we never really know the extent of their involvement with the Taliban. My personal view is they were just poor, traditional tribal villagers who were trying to survive however they could.
Gulwali's mother decides it is no longer safe for her oldest sons so she pays human smugglers to take them to freedom in Europe (we later find out she has paid $8000 each to get them as far as Greece). She accompanies them as far as Peshawar, Pakistan then instructs them to hold each other's hands the whole way and "no matter how hard it gets, never come back". These words haunt Gulwali throughout his lengthy escape. First, because he is separated from his brother by the smugglers in the Peshawar airport and must make the escape entirely on his own. Second, it gets really hard and he desperately longs for the comfort of his mother and grandmother.
Most of the book gives us insight into just how difficult escape is, and how organized a machine human smuggling has become. Gulwali travels from Pakistan to Iran, through Iran, on foot to Turkey, by train to Bulgaria - where he is jailed and returned to Turkey, where he is jailed and returned to Iran. Then from Iran back to Turkey, by leaky boat to Greece, then to Italy, Calais, France and finally England. Along the way he meets the worst of the smugglers who prey upon people's desperation. But he does meet up with some kindness - in other, slightly older, refugees boys who take him under their wing, some of the lowly hosts of refugees who are doing this just to make a living and take pity on a small boy doing this on his own (he is particularly favoured by some of the wives and mothers who feel for him and do what they can, whether it is giving him a bit extra food or slightly better sleeping conditions).
Some of the most vivid descriptions are of makeshift refugee camps in Europe - particularly "the jungle" in Calais. It's eye opening to see what is happening in these supposedly developed countries. In the end Gulwali makes it to the UK alive - but he is permanently scarred both physically (from an aborted attempt to smuggle him across the channel in a truck filled with some sort of chemical powder) and emotionally (he suffers from severe depression, and even attempts suicide at least twice). But he is obviously extremely bright and makes the most of his educational opportunities in the UK. He says he dreams of returning the Afghanistan and one day perhaps becoming its president. Given his remarkable survival skills, I for one believe he probably could become president of Afghanistan one day.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)