As regular followers know, I tend to read lighter fare during the summer. So I will do brief reviews of what I have read over the last few weeks, but for the most part they are not sufficiently deep or complicated to warrant a detailed analysis.
Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn
I have deliberately avoided reading this book as I never find books hyped as heavily as this one was deserve that hype. But I had nothing to read, and this was lying around the house, so I gave it a try. I will say, I didn't hate it (unlike, for example, The Goldfinch). At times I was kept on the edge of my seat trying to figure out what had happened, which was of course the author's intent. I also found the characters interesting, if generally distasteful. I can't really say much more without giving away the plot, and don't bother reading the book if you know the ending as the suspense was by far the best aspect. But I will say after anxiously awaiting the ending I was disappointed in it - I think it was probably the right ending given the personalities of the main characters, but that didn't make it any more satisfying. I suppose I wanted to see justice done as much as all the characters in the book seem to want, but like with them, my wish was not granted.
In the Unlikely Event by Judy Blume
Like many women my age, I eagerly anticipated Judy Blume's newest adult novel, having been an avid fan since picking up Are You There God, It's Me Margaret in fourth grade. And the book did not disappoint - no, it wasn't high level literature fit for discussions in university English classes but it was an entertaining read. The narrative primarily takes place over the course of a year in the 1950s in Elizabeth, New Jersey. In that year (this part is factual) three planes crashed in Elizabeth while trying to land at Newark airport. Many lives were lost both on the airplanes and on the ground. Blume grew up in Elizabeth and lived through this time period so now returns to it to examine the impact it had on the people living there. Her main character is teenaged Miri who lives with her mother, grandmother and uncle having been born to her mother out of wedlock. So in addition to seeing how the plane crashes impact Miri we see her struggle with learning who her father is (and meeting him for the first time), her relationship with her best friend (who is so badly scarred by the plane crashes that she develops anorexia), her first love (with an Irish Catholic boy living in an orphanage who is not her grandmother's first choice) and how she reacts when new loves enter the lives of all the other adults living in her home. At first I was confused by the multitude of characters, but then I got used to why Blume was introducing them (they tended to be somehow involved with the three planes if they were not major players in Miri's life) and I found it easier to follow. She also did a masterful job at eventually weaving together the lives of seemingly unrelated players. In sum, I recommend reading this book, particularly if you are fond of Blume's writing. As an aside, I love the title - derived from the standard airline of safety video - "in the unlikely event of..."
The Rumor by Elin Hilderbrand
Like with Blume, I anxiously await Elin Hildebrand's new summer releases. They are generally set in Nantucket and are perfect light summer reading fare. I have to admit I was a bit disappointed with this one. In fairness, Hilderbrand wrote it while being treated for breast cancer (and is also a young mother) which is incredibly impressive so I have to give her credit for that. The premise of the book is how rumours spread in a small town and the damage they can bring to people's lives. Although, in the end it was actual behaviour rather than rumoured ones that got most of these characters in trouble. The action centres around Madeline King and her husband Trevor, their son, their friends, Grace and Eddie Pancik and their teenaged twin daughters, Eddie's sister, and a landscape architect working on Grace's property. There are also assorted other friends or acquaintances who wander in and out of the narrative. The chapters are written from the perspective of several different characters though it is not hard to follow as this is clearly laid out. The rumours have Madeline having an affair with Eddie (though the reader knows from the start that this is not the case) but in fact it is Grace who gets into relationship troubles and Eddie who gets into financial and legal troubles. At the same time the various teenagers get into relationship troubles of their own. The stories were interesting enough but none of the characters really grabbed me - I didn't really find myself caring who ended up with whom and where. If you have nothing else to read on a summer's day, this isn't terrible but it isn't great either. Some of her earlier books would make a better choice.
The Guest Cottage and An Island Christmas by Nancy Thayer
Thayer is another Nantucket writer who writes Nantucket based beach reads. The Guest Cottage was an entertaining romance with likeable characters. Her books all follow the same basic formula - woman meets man, they try to resist each other for various reasons and then they realize they belong together (usually a welcomed pregnancy is also involved). If you're expecting unpredictable her books aren't for you, but if you want sympathetic characters who get the happy ending they deserve, you won't be disappointed. In this novel, by a series of misunderstandings two different families end up renting out the same beach house for the same summer. The first is Sophie and her 15 year old son Jonah and 8 year old daughter Lacey. Sophie's husband has just announced he wants a divorce so he can marry another woman and Sophie decides to use money inherited from an eccentric aunt to take this vacation and figure out what to do. The second family is Trevor and his four year old son Leo. Trevor's wife has recently died of a drug overdose and his son is developing peculiar behaviours so he decides to take him on vacation to help him heal. That puts Sophie and Trevor in the same house together and given what I said above you can figure out what eventually happens. Though predictable there are some great scenes with the children as well as an elderly man who lives on an adjacent property. Not a bad way to spend a few summer hours. Because I enjoyed the escapism of this book, when I needed to download something else for a plane ride I picked up Thayer's Christmas novel, An Island Christmas. It wasn't as good as the other book but it was okay. It dealt with the story of two very different daughters who return to Nantucket to spend Christmas with their parents and to celebrate the wedding of the younger daughter. Again as might be expected the mother doesn't like her daughter's choice of fiance and wants her to marry a high school boyfriend but in the end discovers that her daughter has in fact made the right choice. There were some very amusing scenes when the mother latches on to a cat to channel her maternal instincts and when the father gets repeatedly injured trying to keep up with his son-in-law to be. So not a great book but served as a good distraction on an airplane.
The Book of Aron by Jim Shepard
This is the only book I read which doesn't fit into the category of easy summer reading - though it wasn't a difficult book to read. This is the story of young Aron, a child trying to survive in the Warsaw Ghetto. He is a bit of a no good street urchin prior to the war and during the war his smuggling skills and questionable connections do serve to keep him alive. He eventually ends up living in Janusz Korcak's orphanage and the book fictionalizes the final days of this famous doctor and the children under his care. The book is written from Aron's perspective so has a very stream of consciousness style which I suppose is intended to represent his youth. Frankly I didn't like the style that much - while I understand what the author was trying to do, it just came off as poorly written. Like the book My Mother's Secret, maybe if this book had been hyped as aimed at young adults I would not have been so disappointed. I thought the story had so much potential, and the book did get good reviews, but I just found it shallow. There was so much opportunity to explore the impact of the war on a misfit child like this and I just don't think the author got there. Perhaps a good book to give a young adult reader a different perspective on the Holocaust but otherwise I'm not sure I'd bother.
The answer to the question I'm always asked about what I'm reading and whether I recommend it.
Wednesday, July 15, 2015
Thursday, June 18, 2015
The Art of Hearing Heartbeats by Jan-Philipp Sendker
This is not a new book, but it was recently recommended to me and it was really interesting. First, it was translated from the German and it still reads beautifully, almost like poetry, which I often find is hard to do in a translation - so kudos both to the author and the translator.
I don't want to give away too much of the plot as the whole premise of the book is watching the past unfold together with the main character. But here's what I can say: Julia Win's father disappears on the morning after her graduation from law school without explanation which is totally out of character for him. He does wake her to tell her he was headed to Boston for a business trip (he was a NY lawyer), and he does go to the airport but he does not fly to Boston. Instead he is eventually traced to Los Angeles, Hong Kong and Bangkok when the trail goes cold. His passport was found near the Bangkok airport and investigators speculate he may have been murdered or in some sort of accident while trying to leave Bangkok.
Four years later (with little explanation for why four years pass), Julia's mother gives her some of her father's personal effects and in them Julia finds an unsent letter to a woman named Mi Mi in her father's native Burma. Julia's mother admits she knows nothing about her husband's first 20 years in Burma, despite desperate pleas for information. The letter appears to be to an old lover and Julia decides to track her down in an effort to find her father.
And this is where the mystery begins. She travels to Burma, marvelling in and suffering from its primitive state, and at a somewhat dirty tea shop is approached by U Ba, an older man who claims he knows her father and his story. Though she is skeptical that he is a scam artist who had been fed information by her hotel she decides to listen to him. Over a few days he paints the picture of her father's past - and the reader is transported 50 years earlier to colonial Burma to learn what happened to him, who Mi Mi was, how Julia's father ended up in the US and what eventually happened to him. I don't want to give any of that away as the careful telling of that story is what makes this book so interesting. I wouldn't say it's the most suspenseful story I've ever read but it certainly takes some interesting twists and turns.
I definitely recommend this book. It is different and, as I said before, beautifully written.
I don't want to give away too much of the plot as the whole premise of the book is watching the past unfold together with the main character. But here's what I can say: Julia Win's father disappears on the morning after her graduation from law school without explanation which is totally out of character for him. He does wake her to tell her he was headed to Boston for a business trip (he was a NY lawyer), and he does go to the airport but he does not fly to Boston. Instead he is eventually traced to Los Angeles, Hong Kong and Bangkok when the trail goes cold. His passport was found near the Bangkok airport and investigators speculate he may have been murdered or in some sort of accident while trying to leave Bangkok.
Four years later (with little explanation for why four years pass), Julia's mother gives her some of her father's personal effects and in them Julia finds an unsent letter to a woman named Mi Mi in her father's native Burma. Julia's mother admits she knows nothing about her husband's first 20 years in Burma, despite desperate pleas for information. The letter appears to be to an old lover and Julia decides to track her down in an effort to find her father.
And this is where the mystery begins. She travels to Burma, marvelling in and suffering from its primitive state, and at a somewhat dirty tea shop is approached by U Ba, an older man who claims he knows her father and his story. Though she is skeptical that he is a scam artist who had been fed information by her hotel she decides to listen to him. Over a few days he paints the picture of her father's past - and the reader is transported 50 years earlier to colonial Burma to learn what happened to him, who Mi Mi was, how Julia's father ended up in the US and what eventually happened to him. I don't want to give any of that away as the careful telling of that story is what makes this book so interesting. I wouldn't say it's the most suspenseful story I've ever read but it certainly takes some interesting twists and turns.
I definitely recommend this book. It is different and, as I said before, beautifully written.
Sunday, June 14, 2015
Underground in Berlin by Marie Jalowicz Simon
This is a fascinating memoir of a young Jewish girl who survived World War II by going underground in the heart of Berlin. It is based on the tapes she made for her son while in her seventies, describing her childhood before the war and then the war years based solely on her memories. The book reads much like a transcript which occasionally makes it hard to follow - I found it particularly difficult to keep track of the many people who came and went. Sometimes I just gave up on trying to remember how a person Marie spoke about had previously played a role in her life - and sometimes she later reminded the reader and sometimes she didn't. Despite that, I recommend reading the book as it is a first hand account of the war years from a perspective you don't often see (since many of her fellow hidden Jews did not survive).
Marie was born into an upper middle class Jewish family in Berlin. She was educated and received her high school diploma just as the war was beginning. Her mother died before the war and her father in 1942. After that she was on her own, working in forced labour for Siemens, and one day decided merely to remove her Jewish star and hide out - but this was not hiding in the sense of Anne Frank, she moved from place to place and carried on from day to day using a false identity given to her by a family friend. So in some ways she was hidden in plain view. It is hard to determine whether she survived due to her naiveté or her wile; luck or good planning, or some combination of all of these traits.
She was certainly helped by a number of non-Jews: the aforementioned woman who gave her the identity card. Marie had a complicated relationship with this woman who made her feel beholden to her, but clearly did provide both refuge and food. Marie also resented the woman, believing she had merely taken over her family's holiday home - it was only in 1994, after the other woman's death, that she discovered it had in fact been sold to her by Marie's father. A Chinese man who offered to marry her in an effort to get her safely to Shanghai; a Bulgarian man who also did so and, for a time, was able to protect her in Bulgaria but she eventually was returned to Berlin; a Dutch foreign worker in Berlin who lived with her for many years as a tenant of an old woman who had Nazi sympathies but nonetheless put up with Marie; a family of circus artists who took her in for a time as well as their Communist friends; the superintendent of the building where she lived with the Dutch man; and others.
After the war, Marie stayed in Berlin - she still considered Germany her home and never judged people merely for being German since so many had helped her survive. This is the story as she told it to her son after 50 years of silence. It is definitely worth reading to see a whole new perspective on this terrible time.
Marie was born into an upper middle class Jewish family in Berlin. She was educated and received her high school diploma just as the war was beginning. Her mother died before the war and her father in 1942. After that she was on her own, working in forced labour for Siemens, and one day decided merely to remove her Jewish star and hide out - but this was not hiding in the sense of Anne Frank, she moved from place to place and carried on from day to day using a false identity given to her by a family friend. So in some ways she was hidden in plain view. It is hard to determine whether she survived due to her naiveté or her wile; luck or good planning, or some combination of all of these traits.
She was certainly helped by a number of non-Jews: the aforementioned woman who gave her the identity card. Marie had a complicated relationship with this woman who made her feel beholden to her, but clearly did provide both refuge and food. Marie also resented the woman, believing she had merely taken over her family's holiday home - it was only in 1994, after the other woman's death, that she discovered it had in fact been sold to her by Marie's father. A Chinese man who offered to marry her in an effort to get her safely to Shanghai; a Bulgarian man who also did so and, for a time, was able to protect her in Bulgaria but she eventually was returned to Berlin; a Dutch foreign worker in Berlin who lived with her for many years as a tenant of an old woman who had Nazi sympathies but nonetheless put up with Marie; a family of circus artists who took her in for a time as well as their Communist friends; the superintendent of the building where she lived with the Dutch man; and others.
After the war, Marie stayed in Berlin - she still considered Germany her home and never judged people merely for being German since so many had helped her survive. This is the story as she told it to her son after 50 years of silence. It is definitely worth reading to see a whole new perspective on this terrible time.
Thursday, June 11, 2015
Crime Seen by Kate Lines
This is not my usual type of book but I heard the author interviewed on the radio and I thought it sounded interesting. For the most part it was, though as a police officer, the author said in the acknowledgments she had trouble writing more than "just the facts" and at times it was a littler dry as a result. But, I was able to skim over those parts and still enjoy the book.
Kate Lines was an early member of the Ontario Provincial Police - when she was first interviewed for the job she met officers who said women had no business being on the force, but nonetheless she was hired and moved through the ranks.
She started in traffic patrol, then moved to undercover, but her career really took off when she was selected to be only the second police officer in Canada to be trained by the FBI in criminal profiling (the first was an RCMP officer with whom she worked closely throughout her career). She details her very interesting training session in the US as part of a group of international students. Her instructors were fascinating FBI agents, many of whom she stayed in touch with after and consulted on difficult cases.
Armed with these profiling skills she consulted on some of Canada's most notorious crimes, including the Paul Bernardo case. Not wanting to make the book about glorifying criminals she focuses on the victims and their families and does a nice job of making them very human. She was clearly respected by them as must have received a lot of cooperation in writing the book.
She glosses over it, but does mention a struggle with post traumatic stress syndrome which caused her to step back from profiling at one time. Eventually she retired from the force and now is a licensed private investigator and consults with business, police forces and even TV shows.
A fairly easy read about a woman's success in a historically non-traditional role for women - hopefully she will continue to inspire more to follow in her footsteps.
Kate Lines was an early member of the Ontario Provincial Police - when she was first interviewed for the job she met officers who said women had no business being on the force, but nonetheless she was hired and moved through the ranks.
She started in traffic patrol, then moved to undercover, but her career really took off when she was selected to be only the second police officer in Canada to be trained by the FBI in criminal profiling (the first was an RCMP officer with whom she worked closely throughout her career). She details her very interesting training session in the US as part of a group of international students. Her instructors were fascinating FBI agents, many of whom she stayed in touch with after and consulted on difficult cases.
Armed with these profiling skills she consulted on some of Canada's most notorious crimes, including the Paul Bernardo case. Not wanting to make the book about glorifying criminals she focuses on the victims and their families and does a nice job of making them very human. She was clearly respected by them as must have received a lot of cooperation in writing the book.
She glosses over it, but does mention a struggle with post traumatic stress syndrome which caused her to step back from profiling at one time. Eventually she retired from the force and now is a licensed private investigator and consults with business, police forces and even TV shows.
A fairly easy read about a woman's success in a historically non-traditional role for women - hopefully she will continue to inspire more to follow in her footsteps.
Wednesday, June 10, 2015
Cold Sea Stories by Pawet Huelle
I'm not sure where to start on reviewing this book, because I'm still not sure I understood all of the stories. I chose this book because I will be visiting Poland later in the year and I wanted to read something by a contemporary Polish author. This short story collection was well reviewed and is by an award winning Polish author who has been translated into many languages.
There were parts of the stories I loved - taking place largely in Gdansk and the surrounding countryside, they provided insight into what it was like to live behind the Iron Curtain, and in Poland during the break from Communism. In an afterward there is an interview with the author who explains that the story The Bicycle Express was largely autobiographical - it details a few days in the life of a teenager who delivers leaflets by bicycle from the Gdansk shipyard where an uprising is taking place to other factories around the city. Perhaps my favourite story was Franz Carl Weber - it tells of a grown man's first visit to Zurich after travel restrictions are lifted. His father, part of the intelligentsia who was tortured during the Communist regime, had traveled to Zurich and brought the narrator and his brother a train set from the Swiss store Franz Carl Weber. Playing with this train set, and studying the store's catalogue, were some of the narrator's happiest memories. In Zurich he is delighted to visit the store but because times have changed is disappointed to find few train sets.
The stories Mimesis and First Summer also taught me a bit about the Mennonite Community from around Gdansk which was all but wiped out by the Nazis due to its pacifism - and what remained was destroyed by the Communists.
The problem I had with the stories is that whenever I was finally getting interested in the characters and their stories, the narrative turned to magical realism. For example, in Franz Carl Weber the author details how as a child at night he went into the fields and rode imaginary trains. These flights of fancy are just not my style and, while I'm sure they were symbolic in ways that escaped me, I would have preferred the narrative stripped of the fantasy.
Despite this flaw, I enjoyed the stories and am glad to have read a bit about Polish culture past and present.
There were parts of the stories I loved - taking place largely in Gdansk and the surrounding countryside, they provided insight into what it was like to live behind the Iron Curtain, and in Poland during the break from Communism. In an afterward there is an interview with the author who explains that the story The Bicycle Express was largely autobiographical - it details a few days in the life of a teenager who delivers leaflets by bicycle from the Gdansk shipyard where an uprising is taking place to other factories around the city. Perhaps my favourite story was Franz Carl Weber - it tells of a grown man's first visit to Zurich after travel restrictions are lifted. His father, part of the intelligentsia who was tortured during the Communist regime, had traveled to Zurich and brought the narrator and his brother a train set from the Swiss store Franz Carl Weber. Playing with this train set, and studying the store's catalogue, were some of the narrator's happiest memories. In Zurich he is delighted to visit the store but because times have changed is disappointed to find few train sets.
The stories Mimesis and First Summer also taught me a bit about the Mennonite Community from around Gdansk which was all but wiped out by the Nazis due to its pacifism - and what remained was destroyed by the Communists.
The problem I had with the stories is that whenever I was finally getting interested in the characters and their stories, the narrative turned to magical realism. For example, in Franz Carl Weber the author details how as a child at night he went into the fields and rode imaginary trains. These flights of fancy are just not my style and, while I'm sure they were symbolic in ways that escaped me, I would have preferred the narrative stripped of the fantasy.
Despite this flaw, I enjoyed the stories and am glad to have read a bit about Polish culture past and present.
Monday, June 8, 2015
Another weekend, another two books
I read these books quickly, and there were some similarities between the books. Both are set in the past: Church of Marvels by Leslie Parry in 1890s New York City; and At the Water's Edge by Sara Gruen in 1940s Scotland. Both revolve around trouble women: Odile Church, a performer in a Coney Island sideshow whose mother has just died in a fire and who is search for her sister, Belle, who has fled to Manhattan; and Madeleine Hyde, who is trapped in an unhappy marriage and forced by her husband to travel the ocean during war time to search for the Loch Ness monster. Both have an overbearing mother-in-law who did not want their sons to marry the wives they did marry, Alphie's in Church of Marvels and Madeleine's in At the Water's Edge. And both deal with issues of sexual preference and identity - I will not reveal the details of this in either book as that aspect is part of the suspense that needs to unfold naturally. And both are well written and easy to read - though with more characters and changing perspectives I found Church of Marvels a bit harder to follow.
Church of Marvels really deals with three separate stories - and the fun is figuring out how they all come together. I discussed Odile and her sister Belle above. There is also Sylvan, a night-soiler who cleans out Manhattan privies. One night when doing so he finds a baby - and his mystery is finding out who the baby belongs to and why she was discarded. Finally there is Alphie, who wakes up in an asylum and, having been hit on the head, cannot remember why or how she got there. Her mystery is figuring that out and, more importantly, how to escape. I really do not want to reveal much more about the stories as there were a lot of surprises - many completely unexpected and I'm usually pretty good at figuring out the clues. But this was a good read and an interesting insight into the lower classes in 1890s New York.
In At the Water's Edge, Maddie's husband, Ellis, is unable to enlist due to colour blindness - for this and his drunken rants against his father, he has alienated his parents. In order to regain their favour he and his best friend convince Maddie they must go to Scotland to find the Loch Ness monster, a task which Ellis' father had failed to accomplish despite desperate efforts. Maddie is uncomfortable crossing the ocean in wartime, but a traditional wife, with no independent means, she has no choice but to follow her husband. When she arrives in Scotland, at first she tries to assist in the monster hunt, but eventually Ellis and his friend exclude her more and more often. So she befriends the staff at the inn where they are staying (which angers her husband who does not think she should fraternize with the help). Through these friendships she learns more about herself and her marriage - and figures out where the monsters truly reside. As usual Gruen has written a well-researched but easily accessible historical fiction.
I recommend both of these books, though if you only have time for one, I would choose At the Water's Edge; it is better written.
Church of Marvels really deals with three separate stories - and the fun is figuring out how they all come together. I discussed Odile and her sister Belle above. There is also Sylvan, a night-soiler who cleans out Manhattan privies. One night when doing so he finds a baby - and his mystery is finding out who the baby belongs to and why she was discarded. Finally there is Alphie, who wakes up in an asylum and, having been hit on the head, cannot remember why or how she got there. Her mystery is figuring that out and, more importantly, how to escape. I really do not want to reveal much more about the stories as there were a lot of surprises - many completely unexpected and I'm usually pretty good at figuring out the clues. But this was a good read and an interesting insight into the lower classes in 1890s New York.
In At the Water's Edge, Maddie's husband, Ellis, is unable to enlist due to colour blindness - for this and his drunken rants against his father, he has alienated his parents. In order to regain their favour he and his best friend convince Maddie they must go to Scotland to find the Loch Ness monster, a task which Ellis' father had failed to accomplish despite desperate efforts. Maddie is uncomfortable crossing the ocean in wartime, but a traditional wife, with no independent means, she has no choice but to follow her husband. When she arrives in Scotland, at first she tries to assist in the monster hunt, but eventually Ellis and his friend exclude her more and more often. So she befriends the staff at the inn where they are staying (which angers her husband who does not think she should fraternize with the help). Through these friendships she learns more about herself and her marriage - and figures out where the monsters truly reside. As usual Gruen has written a well-researched but easily accessible historical fiction.
I recommend both of these books, though if you only have time for one, I would choose At the Water's Edge; it is better written.
Thursday, June 4, 2015
The Invention of Wings by Sue Monk Kidd
I enjoyed this book but somehow I still found it a bit unimaginative. The story of a southern white woman who takes up the abolitionist cause, as well as her personal slave who she struggles to free, just seemed like one that I had read before - though I hadn't already read this particular book. Of course, until I read the author's notes at the end, I did not know how much of this story was based in fact - which in retrospect made the story more interesting.
The story is based upon the life of Sarah Grimke, a woman born into a slave owning family in Charleston who, together with her younger sister, Angelina, forsake the life they are born into and move north to become the first women to speak out in favour of abolition. Because of the constraints put on her life, Sarah, who had wanted first to become a lawyer then a Quaker minister, becomes a vocal feminist as well. This causes some rift within the mainstream abolitionist movement who feel it detracts from their main goal. While Kidd includes these factual aspects of the Grimke sisters' lives, she flushes out the details, in particular, giving voice to one of the Grimke slaves, Handful.
The story starts on Sarah's eleventh birthday, when she is given ownership of ten year old Handful to be her personal maid (Handful is even "wrapped" in purple bows for the occasion). Uncomfortable with this from the start, she uses a book written by her father, a judge, to draft a document granting Handful her freedom, but it is ripped up by her parents who say she must respect their way of life. Despite that she vows to Handful's mother to find a way to grant Handful her freedom - and starts by secretly teaching her how to read.
The book alternates chapters between Sarah and Handful and carries us into their adult lives. Along the way we witness discrimination against women - Sarah's father and brothers mock her desire to be a lawyer and her mother pushes her to find a husband though she proves very unlucky with men. But we witness even greater cruelty to slaves and even free blacks like the boyfriend of Handful's mother who tries to organize and insurrection (and is also based on an actual person).
And throughout we witness Sarah's struggle to find a way to keep her vow to free Handful - but she must work against her parents and later her sister and it is not easy to accomplish even when she has the money to "buy" her back from her mother just so she can set her free.
In the end we are given some glimmer of hope that slavery will come to an end, but see why discrimination will continue for decades - as even the staunch abolitionists do not have equality as a goal.
The story is based upon the life of Sarah Grimke, a woman born into a slave owning family in Charleston who, together with her younger sister, Angelina, forsake the life they are born into and move north to become the first women to speak out in favour of abolition. Because of the constraints put on her life, Sarah, who had wanted first to become a lawyer then a Quaker minister, becomes a vocal feminist as well. This causes some rift within the mainstream abolitionist movement who feel it detracts from their main goal. While Kidd includes these factual aspects of the Grimke sisters' lives, she flushes out the details, in particular, giving voice to one of the Grimke slaves, Handful.
The story starts on Sarah's eleventh birthday, when she is given ownership of ten year old Handful to be her personal maid (Handful is even "wrapped" in purple bows for the occasion). Uncomfortable with this from the start, she uses a book written by her father, a judge, to draft a document granting Handful her freedom, but it is ripped up by her parents who say she must respect their way of life. Despite that she vows to Handful's mother to find a way to grant Handful her freedom - and starts by secretly teaching her how to read.
The book alternates chapters between Sarah and Handful and carries us into their adult lives. Along the way we witness discrimination against women - Sarah's father and brothers mock her desire to be a lawyer and her mother pushes her to find a husband though she proves very unlucky with men. But we witness even greater cruelty to slaves and even free blacks like the boyfriend of Handful's mother who tries to organize and insurrection (and is also based on an actual person).
And throughout we witness Sarah's struggle to find a way to keep her vow to free Handful - but she must work against her parents and later her sister and it is not easy to accomplish even when she has the money to "buy" her back from her mother just so she can set her free.
In the end we are given some glimmer of hope that slavery will come to an end, but see why discrimination will continue for decades - as even the staunch abolitionists do not have equality as a goal.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)